Andrew McLaughlin has successfully defended a claim worth in excess of £800,000 following a five-day trial in which the claimant was found to have been fundamentally dishonest in the presentation of his claim.

The claim arose from an accident in which the claimant, Mr Sheikhipour, fell from a ladder while holding a large pane of window glass, sustaining multiple fractures to his spine. Primary liability was admitted.

The claimant alleged that, as a result of his injuries, he was severely disabled, had been unable to work and was dependent on his family for care and assistance with ordinary activities of daily living. He claimed state benefits of approximately £135,000 on the basis of these assertions and alleged that his injuries had led to a four-year separation from his wife of 20 years.

The case went to trial over 5 days in August 2026. On the first day, it emerged that the defendant company had been struck off the Register only a few weeks before trial, leading the Judge to indicate that the case would have to be adjourned. The Judge gave the defendant’s legal team 24 hours to find a solution.

An application to restore the company was made and listed the following day. Following two appearances before a District Judge in the Chancery Division of the Birmingham District Registry, Andrew McLaughlin of 12KBW successfully persuaded the court to grant restoration with immediate effect, allowing the trial to continue. The restoration process would ordinarily take considerably longer.

Mr Sheikhipour was subsequently cross-examined over two days. His wife, who was due to give evidence, declined to do so. Expert evidence was heard in the fields of orthopaedics (spine and shoulder), pain and psychiatry.

In his reserved judgment, handed down this month, the Judge found that Mr Sheikhipour had been fundamentally dishonest in the presentation of his claim. The Judge found that claimant lied about the cause of the breakdown of his relationship with his wife and had recovered sufficiently to return to work after 12 months.

The claimant was awarded damages of £31,447.50, net of a finding of 25% contributory fault. The Judge also found that the claimant had lied to the DWP about his alleged disability and ordered the defendant’s solicitors to send a copy of the judgment to the DWP.

Andrew McLaughlin was instructed by Helen Falconer of DAC Beachcroft for Covéa Insurance.

Read the full judgment here.